SANZAR to trial new disciplinary rules during Vodacom Super Rugby

Feb 2 • International, IRB Laws, National, Super Rugby, Super Rugby News, World Rugby • 7884 Views • Comments Off on SANZAR to trial new disciplinary rules during Vodacom Super Rugby

SANZAR is to trial new disciplinary rules during the 2012 Super Rugby competition, CEO Greg Peters announced on Thursday.

The changes follow a cross-country Working Group meeting with representatives across all areas of the game held in September last year, which conducted a ‘clean sheet’ review of the SANZAR judicial process.

The objectives of the review were to provide a system that is fair, consistent and simple with fewer full hearings and consequently reduced costs.

“SANZAR has long held the view that the disciplinary process could be enhanced to provide for a more consistent and simplified outcome,” said Peters.

“We believe that these changes are an important step in the right direction”.

Key Changes:

1 On-field Referee Referral to Citing Commissioner

Instances where a referee thinks an act of foul play has occurred but is not sure if a red card is warranted, or is unsure of the identity of a player
Where a player makes a complaint to a referee who did not see an incident
Can be in addition to a yellow card or penalty
Referred to the Citing Commissioner for review

2 Citing Commissioner issues an “Off-Field Yellow Card”

Instances where a Citing Commissioner observes a serious act of foul play that is close to but not quite a red card
The Off-field yellow card is logged on the player’s disciplinary record in the same manner as an On-Field yellow card

3 Duty Judicial Officer

Performs an initial assessment of citings, red cards or three yellow cards
Duty Judicial Officer may hold a brief teleconference with the player and/or his representative
Determines whether or not to offer the player a preliminary indication of penalty
May refer to a full judicial hearing
The player must accept he committed an act of foul play to be offered an indication of penalty
If player does not accept the indication of penalty the matter will be referred to full hearing

4 Judicial Hearings

Where a full judicial hearing is required it will be held by videoconference or teleconference with ‘in-person’ hearings only taking place in exceptional circumstances
Other processes for the hearing will be the same as previously

5 Appeals

SANZAR has a right of appeal the outcome of a judicial hearing on the following grounds:

– Where there is substantial unfairness, or the penalty imposed on a player is clearly excessive or inadequate

– Where there has been a fundamental error by the Judicial Officer in reaching his decision

Normal rights of Appeal apply for players

The SANZAR trial has been approved by the International Rugby Board (IRB) and will form an important part of the IRB’s own full review of Regulation 17 that governs the disciplinary process internationally.

The new system will come into operation when the Super Rugby tournament kicks off on February 24.